Food

Cookie Advent Calendar – The Secret to Non-Spreading Sugar Cookies is CORN STARCH

The Inspiration

A very good friend linked me to contellationinspiration, which inspired me to create a cookie advent calendar. I don’t deal with icing or decorating much, so I used most of Amy’s color scheme and shapes. The whole process has been VERY interesting; I really felt like I was doing a at-home British Bakeoff where they say, “you have 3 hours to create a holiday cookie centerpiece. Ready, set, BAKE!”

Sugar Cookie > Gingerbread Cookie (taste)

Gingerbread is typically the go-to type of cookie for shaping and decorating (think gingerbread houses), but I don’t enjoy the taste of gingerbread. I wanted the display to be edible and delicious, so I went with sugar cookie because I like it and my kids like it too.

Avoid that Cookie Spreading

Cookie spread can be a beautiful thing, especially if the plan is to go directly from baking to eating. On the other hand, cookies that don’t spread as much are more ideal for decorating with icing. A lot of what we see is gingerbread, as it’s traditional, sturdy, and holds well over long distances (think boxed gingerbread kits). Shortbread cookies retain their shape well and are also great for decorating, but they tend to crack and crumble fairly easily. Sugar cookies are similar to shortbread (they have eggs, where shortbread do not, and somewhat a different ratio of flour/butter/etc), with the advantage of being more sturdy for larger shaped cookies.

Recipe (See Above Images for Pics of the Early Steps):

Ingredients –

For the Cookie Dough (you may want to make 2 batches in case you need more or if there is a mishap) – 

  • 4 Cups Flour
  • 1/3 Cup Corn Starch
  • 1/2 Tsp Salt
  • 1 Cup Unsalted Butter (softened)
  • 1 Cup Sugar
  • 2 Large Eggs
  • 1.5 Tsp Vanilla Extract

For the Icing (make multiple batches as needed) – 

  • 1 Cup Confectioners’ Sugar
  • 4 Tsp Milk
  • 2 Tsp Light Corn Syrup
  • 1/3 Tsp Almond Extract
  • Various Food Coloring

Instructions –

Make the Cookie Dough  –

  1. Sift flour, corn starch, and sale in a bowl, and mix together.
  2. Cream the butter and sugar together in a large bowl, approximately 2-3 minutes
  3. Add in the eggs while mixing the butter and sugar, scrape down the sides of the bowl as needed
  4. Add in the vanilla
  5. Pour in the flour mixture and mix until well incorporated

Form the Dough and  Bake –

  1. Roll out the dough to 1/4 inch thick and create your shapes
  2. For the Advent Calendar Base – I put parchment paper on a baking tray and made a rectangle, cut 25 squares into it (each 2 in x 2 in), and then cleaned up the edges to desired shape.
  3. For the cookies – Save all the squares from above. Also cut out 25 additional cookies that are smaller than the squares.
  4. Put the formed cookies (calendar base, 25 squares, 25 mini cookies) in the fridge for 30+ minutes.
  5. Bake at 375F for –
    *small cookies – 10 – 12 minutes
    *squares (2 inches) – 12 – 14 mins
    *calendar base – 12 – 15 mins
  6. Let cool to room temperature

Make the Icing and Decorate –

  1. Stir together the confectioners sugar and milk into a small bowl
  2. Add in the light corn syrup and stir well
  3. Add in the almond extract and stir well (add in more milk or corn syrup if too think, and add in more confectioners sugar if too thin)
  4. Divide into smaller bowls and add in/mix food coloring to desired colors

DECORATE! Let Dry, and Assemble.

Decorating Order

I alternated between decorating and mixing new icing. I decorated the squares first because that seemed the easiest with a solid color to cover the square and a complimentary color to write down a number. In retrospect, the best way to start decorating would probably have been with the small cookies so they could dry first in order to place the numbered squares on top. The ideal order to decorate would be small cookies, big calendar cookie, then squares; however, if your big calendar cookie has parts sunk in, it may be better to decorate it before the small cookies.

Time it Took

I took breaks here and there between baking and decorating, but I would say in total the process was around 3 hours. Making and baking the cookies was fast, and they didn’t need that much time to cool down. The decorating took the longest, but that is mostly because I’m not used to using icing and decorating with it. I didn’t decorate until after dinner and some TV, so I was rushing to decorate the small cookies with very little thought. Luckily, the creative juices were flowing (from Amy’s inspiration since I nearly copied hers), giving me inspiration regarding color schemes and whatnot.

Afterthoughts

It was a fun bake! Glad I tried something new.

One Comment

  • Sunny

    They turned out great!! I also didn’t realize the differences between different types of cookies, thank you for sharing!